Carey's Rental Outlet

Carey's Lumber & Building Supply has been a proud part of the Penn Yan & Finger Lakes Community since 1933. As a locally owned and operated small business, we are dedicated to providing our customers with the highest quality products and services. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff, with decades of experience, is here to support you every step of the way.

At Carey's, we believe that building a strong foundation is the key to any successful project. That's why we offer a variety of premium brands and products for your construction needs, from foundation to roofing, and everything in between. Whether you're a professional contractor or a DIY homeowner, we've got the materials you need for your commercial and residential new construction, remodeling, or renovation projects.

Our Products

Our extensive range of products includes foundation, concrete, masonry, lumber, OSB, plywood, insulation, drywall, millwork, specialty items, windows, doors, roofing, siding, decking, railing systems, hardware, fasteners, tools, aggregate, hardscapes, mulch, heating fuels, and household specialty items. We're more than just a supply store; we're your one-stop shop for all your construction needs.

We're committed to helping you build better. With a variety of concrete and foundation products available, we can help you get your project started on the right foot. Our selection of lumber and engineered lumber products ensures that your structure will be strong, sturdy, and reliable. For optimal performance, we offer high-quality insulation and drywall products that will keep your home comfortable and energy-efficient.

If you're looking to transform your home, our range of windows and doors can provide the perfect solution. For outdoor living, our decking and railing systems offer long-lasting, low-maintenance options. We also have a wide variety of hardware, fasteners, and tools to help you get the job done right.

Why Choose Carey's?

At Carey's, we're dedicated to providing you with the best products and services available. As a locally owned and operated business, we're proud to be part of the Penn Yan & Finger Lakes Community. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff has decades of experience and is always ready to support you throughout your project.

We offer access to a variety of premium brands and products, ensuring that you have everything you need for your project, from foundation to roofing. We also provide free quotes, project planning, and other special resources to help make your project a success.

So why choose Carey's? Because we're more than just a supply store. We're your partner in building a better future.